Showing posts with label FIDIC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FIDIC. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
Quantum meruit and its scope
Quantum meruit and its scope
The basic principle under English law for claims under quantum
meruit is that the employer will have a duty to pay the fair value of or,
reasonable remuneration for, the work performed. ADAM WEBSTER* compares the
provision with the UAE Civil Code.
Quantum meruit entitlements arise most commonly in construction
cases where there is no contract but work is undertaken in circumstances where
it is clearly not being done for free.
In Latin, the phrase means “what the job is worth” and in
essence, it allows a person to recover the value of work done or services
performed in circumstances where he has conferred a benefit on someone else
which justice requires should be repaid.
A typical quantum meruit claim might arise where work starts whilst the parties
are negotiating contract terms but ultimately the parties have not agreed on
the applicable rate that is to be paid to the contractor or fail to agree any
contract at all.
Alternatively, where the work that has been carried out by a contractor with
the employer’s consent or upon his instruction is so different from the scope
of work envisaged in the original contract that a new contract has effectively
been formed, the contractor may be entitled to claim a quantum meruit for the
additional work done.
The law will not deny the contractor an entitlement to payment, and the basic
principle in English law is that the employer will have a duty to pay the fair
value of or, reasonable remuneration for, the work performed. Issues will
inevitably arise, however, as to the appropriate basis for valuation.
It is often thought that quantum meruit valuations are highly advantageous to
contractors and that invariably they will open the door to “cost plus”
entitlement, that is the net cost of labour and materials used plus a sum for
overheads and profit. In truth, there is a great deal of case law on quantum
meruit with a range of different approaches having been taken. As HHJ Hicks
held in Serck Controls v Drake & Scull Engineering Limited (2000) 73 ConLR
100:
“A quantum meruit claim may …arise… across a spectrum which ranges at one end
from an express contract to do work at an unquantified price, which expressly
or by implication must be a reasonable one, to work (at the other extreme) done
by an uninvited intruder which nevertheless confers on the recipient a benefit
which, for some reason, such as estoppel or acquiescence, it is unjust for him
to retain without making some restitution to the provider … At the first end of
the spectrum … the measure should clearly be the reasonable remuneration of the
claimant; at the other, it should be the value to the defendant. In between
there is a borderline, the position of which may be debateable.”
Clearly, this is an area of the law where judges in English courts have some
discretion and results are by no means predictable. Indeed, the recent case of
ERDC Group Limited v Brunel University (2006) 109 ConLR 114 usefully highlights
the inherent uncertainties and risks which abound when contractors are entitled
to be paid on a quantum meruit basis.
In short, ERDC successfully tendered for the design and construction of a new
sports facility at Brunel University’s Uxbridge campus, but a delay in
obtaining planning permission meant that Brunel had to instruct ERDC to
commence work under a letter of intent.
This letter of intent was relatively lengthy and detailed and Brunel agreed to
pay for any work that was done on the basis of certain valuation rules (which
were to apply to the contract when signed). The letter authorised work to
proceed for a stipulated period of time within which a formal contract was to
be executed. Three more letters were to follow, each one extending further this
deadline. During this period, ERDC had applied for payment on the basis of its
tender rates and prices and applying JCT principles. After the expiry of the
last letter of intent, no formal contract was in place, but ERDC continued to
work.
In this case, the judge was satisfied that all the usual requirements for a
contract were present until the expiry of the last letter (that is September 1,
2002) and so, as there had been a contract until then, ERDC was entitled to be
paid in accordance with rates and prices determined under the valuation rules
that had been incorporated into that contract.
From September 1, 2002 onwards, however, the contract was found not to apply,
and so ERDC was entitled to be paid reasonable remuneration for the benefit
that the university had received.
In assessing what would be a fair and reasonable sum, the judge agreed with a
comment made by Brunel’s quantum expert that “a price or rate that was
reasonable before September 1, in my opinion, does not become unreasonable after September
1 simply because
the authority in the letter of appointment expires”.
The fact that ERDC’s tender was shown to have been commercial and close to
others supported the conclusion that continuing to use ERDC’s rates and prices,
in many instances, were fair. For certain other items, however, where works had
been prolonged beyond the period contemplated by the rates and additional costs
had been incurred by ERDC as a result, or if it were appropriate to do so under
the valuation rules, the Judge held that “cost plus” should be the appropriate
valuation method.
As this case illustrates, under English law the position is far from being
clear cut and cost plus entitlement should certainly not be assumed as a given
by the contractor. By comparison, therefore, the question presents itself
whether the UAE law contains, within its codified civil system, any provisions
that address the notion of quantum meruit in a more straightforward manner.
Article 888 of the UAE Civil Code (“the Code”) applies where the parties have
not agreed remuneration and the issue of a contractor’s entitlement to a
reasonable remuneration arises. In this regard, Article 888 provides that, if
the consideration for the work is not specified in a contract, the contractor
is entitled to ‘fair compensation’, together with the value of the labour and
materials he has provided (that is a cost plus approach).
Article 887 of the Code provides that a contractor may not demand any increase
over a contractually agreed lump sum. Although the contractor assumes the risk
in such a case for any cost overrun in carrying out the agreed lump sum works,
it should not necessarily preclude a contractor from claiming payment on a cost
plus basis for authorised works which fall outside the original scope of lump
sum works.
However, Article 887 then goes on to provide that if any variation or addition
is made to the scope of works with the consent of the employer, the existing
agreement with the contractor must continue to be observed.
Under UAE law, therefore, an entitlement to an increase price for lump sum
contracts is generally denied, subject only to variations or additions, the
pricing of which should be assessed in the context of the overall work carried
out. In the event that the employer instructs work that is out of scope and
there are no applicable rates and prices under the contract, the contractor
would be entitled to claim compensation by way of Article 888 and claim ‘fair
compensation’, presumably on a cost plus basis.
Sunday, February 16, 2014
FIDIC Conditions Explained - Lesson 03
Engineer’s Role – 1987 v 1999 Red Book
FIDIC 1987-Fourth Edition-Clause 2.1-Engineer’s Duties and
Authority
(a)
The
Engineer shall carry out the duties specified in the Contract.
(b)
The
Engineer may exercise the authority specified in or necessarily to be implied
from the Contract, provided however that if the Engineer is required, under the
terms of his appointment by the Employer, to obtain the specific approval
of the Employer before exercising any such authority, particulars of such
requirements shall be set out in part II of these Conditions. Provided further
that any requisite approval shall be deemed to have been given by the Employer
for any such authority exercised by the Engineer.
(c)
Except
as expressly stated in the Contract, the Engineer shall have no authority to
relieve the Contractor of any of his obligation under the Contract.
FIDIC 1987-Fourth Edition-Clause 2.6-Engineer to Act Impartially
Wherever, under the Contract, the
Engineer is required to exercise his discretion by:
(a)
giving
his decision, opinion or consent
(b)
expressing
his satisfaction or approval
(c)
determining value, or
(d)
otherwise
taking action which may affect the rights and obligations of the Employer or
the Contractor
he shall exercise such discretion impartially within the terms of the Contract and having regard to all the
circumstances. Any such decision, opinion, consent, expression of
satisfaction, or approval, determination of value or action may be opened up,
reviewed or revised as provided in Clause 67.
FIDIC 1999-First Edition-Clause 3.1-Engineer’s Duties and Authority
The Employer shall appoint the
Engineer who shall carry out the duties assigned to him in the Contract. The
Engineer’s staff shall include suitably qualified engineers and other
professionals who are competent to carry out these duties.
The Engineer shall have no authority
to amend the Contract.
The Engineer may exercise the
authority attributable to the Engineer as specified in or necessarily to be
implied from the Contract. If the Engineer is required to obtain the
approval of the Employer before exercising a specified authority, the
requirements shall be as stated in the Particular Conditions. The Employer
undertakes not to impose further constraints on the Engineer’s authority,
except as agreed with the Contractor.
However, whenever the Engineer
exercises a specified authority for which the Employer’s approval is required,
then (for the purposes of the Contract) the Employer shall be deemed to have
given approval.
Except as otherwise stated in these
Conditions:
(a)
Whenever
carrying out duties or exercising authority, specified in or implied by the Contract,
the Engineer shall be deemed to act for
the Employer;
(b)
the
Engineer has no authority to relieve either Party of any duties, obligations or
responsibilities under the Contract; and
(c)
any
approval, check, certificate, consent, examination, inspection, instruction,
notice, proposal, request, test, or similar act by the Engineer (including
absence of disapproval ) shall not relieve the Contractor from any
responsibility he has under the Contract, including responsibility for errors,
omissions, discrepancies and
non-compliances.
What is the major difference between
1987 and 1999 red book regarding this clause?
According to 1987 Red Book, Engineer has to cat impartially. But
according to the FIDIC Red Book 1999 Engineer shall be deemed to act for the
Employer. According to 1987 Red Book Engineer may review his determinations as
provided in clause 67 (settlement of disputes). Then who will take over such
duties towards settlement of disputes as per 1999 Red Book? Read clause 20
which states regarding Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB). We will discuss this
in future sessions.
By:
OQSC Journal
On
6:47 PM
Monday, February 10, 2014
FIDIC Conditions Explained - Lesson 02
We will discuss the most
important clauses of FIDIC Red Book 1987 and 1999 in this column.
FIDIC Red Book 1987-Fourth
Edition
Clause 5.2-Priority of Contract
Documents
The
Several documents forming the Contract are to be taken as mutually explanatory
of one another, but in case of ambiguities or discrepancies the
same shall be explained and adjusted by the Engineer who shall
thereupon issue to the Contractor instructions thereon and in such event, unless
otherwise provided in the Contract, the priority of the documents
forming the Contract hall be as follows:
1. The Contract
Agreement (If completed);
2. The Letter of
Acceptance;
3. The Tender;
4. Part 1 of these
conditions and
5. Any other document
forming part of the Contract
FIDIC Red Book 1999-First Edition
Clause 1.5-Priority of Documents
The
documents forming the Contract are to be taken as mutually explanatory of one
another. For the purposes of interpretation, the priority of the
documents shall be in accordance with the following sequence:
a) the
Contract Agreement (If any),
b) the
Letter of Acceptance,
c) the
Letter of Tender,
d) the
Particular Conditions,
e) these
General Conditions,
f) the
Specification,
g) the
Drawings, and
h) the
Schedules and any other documents forming part of the
Contract.
If
an ambiguity or discrepancy is found in the documents, the Engineer
shall issue any necessary clarification or instruction.
What are the other documents?
Following are some of other documents which we could evidence frequently:
a. Post
tender correspondence
b. Minutes
of the post tender meetings –
c. Appendix
to Tender (if not a part of Tender as mentioned above)
Post tender correspondence and
minutes of meetings may be has a higher priority than other documents Care
should be taken regarding the Appendix to Tender which the contractor has used
as a base of his price. There are around 30 clauses of conditions of contract
which reflect in Appendix to Tender.
As
a conclusion there is no much difference between 1987 and 1999 Red Book in this
clause.
Ambiguity
= Ambiguity means that what a thing is, is not clear.
Discrepancy
= Discrepancy is an illogical or surprising lack
of compatibility or similarity between two or more facts.
Similar words:
|
inconsistency, difference, disparity, variance, variation, deviation, divergence, disagreement, dissimilarity, dissimilitude, mismatch, lack of similarity, contrariety, contradictoriness, disaccord, discordance, incongruity, lack of congruence,
incompatibility, irreconcilability, conflict, opposition More.
|
By:
OQSC Journal
On
8:49 PM
Saturday, February 8, 2014
FIDIC Conditions Explained - Lesson 01
Dear Members,
As we promised we are starting the FIDIC Condition Clauses explained lessons series from today.
FIDIC Rainbow suite
FIDIC is the French acronym of International Federation of
Consulting Engineers. It was formed in 1913 by 3 national associations of
consulting Engineers. Now it has 86 members of national associations.
FIDIC has forms for following agreements between:
· Employer and
Contractor (designed by Employer)
· Client and Consultant
· Joint ventures between
consultants
· Sub consultant
agreements
· Representative
agreements
FIDIC Employer/contractor agreement was issued in 1957. From
then there were several editions of various types of forms.
FIDIC issued three contracts for major works;
Red Book – Conditions of Contracts for works designed by the
Employer, also known as the ‘construction contract’.
Orange Book – Design & Build Projects
Yellow book – Conditions of contract for plant &
design-build for electrical & mechanical plant and for building &
engineering works designed by the contractor, also know as the Plant, Design &
Build contract.
Silver Book – Conditions of contract for EPC/Turn Key projects
also known as the EPC/Turnkey contract (EPC = Engineering, Procurement and
Construction)
Other FIDIC issued contracts
Green Book – short form of contract
White Book – Contract between Client and Consultant
Pink Book – Contract for Multilateral Development Bank
Harmonized version of Red Book
Gold Book – Design Build and Operate contracts
We will explain the important clauses of FIDIC 1987 and 1999
versions in detail in our future lessons.
OQSC
By:
OQSC Journal
On
1:00 AM
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)
